Quote: HunterhillDoes anyone know if the slots are going to remain class11 or are they being changed to class111
link to original post
Genting is not a tribe!
Quote: DieterQuote: HunterhillDoes anyone know if the slots are going to remain class11 or are they being changed to class111
link to original post
Genting is not a tribe!
link to original post
We will have to just call them class lottery.
I know they are not a tribe but I thought when NY state decided to allow gambling that they could be class111 casinos. So are del lago and resorts world Catskills class11 or class111?Quote: DieterQuote: HunterhillDoes anyone know if the slots are going to remain class11 or are they being changed to class111
link to original post
Genting is not a tribe!
link to original post
Quote: HunterhillI know they are not a tribe but I thought when NY state decided to allow gambling that they could be class111 casinos. So are del lago and resorts world Catskills class11 or class111?Quote: DieterQuote: HunterhillDoes anyone know if the slots are going to remain class11 or are they being changed to class111
link to original post
Genting is not a tribe!
link to original post
link to original post
Class II and Class III are distinctions within IGRA88.
New York Gaming Commission makes distinctions as Horse Racing & Pari-mutuel gaming, Video Lottery Gaming, and Casino Gaming. (There may be others.)
so if there is laws associated with those games on some NY gaming website... you dont need to rely on rumors or people... both unreliable to begin with
Quote: HunterhillI know they are not a tribe but I thought when NY state decided to allow gambling that they could be class111 casinos. So are del lago and resorts world Catskills class11 or class111?Quote: DieterQuote: HunterhillDoes anyone know if the slots are going to remain class11 or are they being changed to class111
link to original post
Genting is not a tribe!
link to original post
link to original post
Any tribal casino, that is in a state that ALSO has class 3, has the ability to offer class 3 casino products... probably pending approval or something like that before it happens
Take for instance in PA we have Wind Creek... in most of the other states Wind Creek is tribal... but since PA allows class 3 and Wind creek also exists in PA where other class 3 casinos exist, they can also offer class 3 games...
Im pretty sure what Im saying is from the IGRA website
"tell me about the casino gaming in new york state and if it resembles class 3, or lottery"
...
New York is one of the most **hybridized gambling systems in the U.S.**—it uses **both true Class III casino gaming AND lottery-based gaming that looks like casinos**. That’s why it often feels confusing.
Here’s the clean breakdown:
---
# 🧠 The key idea (ELI5)
* Some NY “casinos” are **real Vegas-style (Class III)**
* Some are actually **lottery systems disguised as casinos (VLTs)**
* Some tribal properties even mix both depending on agreements
---
# 🎰 1. TRUE Class III casino gaming (real casino)
This is what most people think of as a casino.
### What it includes:
* Blackjack, roulette, craps
* Poker
* True slot machines (RNG-based, house edge)
👉 Defined as:
* Games where you **play against the house** ([Wikipedia][1])
### Where in NY:
* Tribal casinos with compacts
* Commercial casinos (like the newer upstate resorts)
### Important detail:
* These operate under **tribal–state compacts** and are jointly regulated ([Gaming Commission][2])
👉 Example behavior:
* Slot spins are decided locally by an RNG (like Vegas)
---
# 🎟️ 2. Lottery-based gaming (VLTs / “racinos”)
This is where New York gets unusual.
### What they look like:
* Slot machines
* Video poker
* Electronic table games
### But what they actually are:
* **Lottery terminals (VLTs)**
* Outcomes often determined by a **central system or pre-determined pool** ([Professor Slots][3])
👉 Think:
> More like a **scratch-off ticket with a slot machine animation**
### Key traits:
* Controlled by the **New York State Lottery** ([Professor Slots][3])
* Often no real “house vs player” dynamic
* May be:
* Central-draw system (like tickets)
* Or RNG monitored centrally
### Where:
* Racetracks (“racinos”)
* Some large facilities like Resorts World NYC
---
# ⚠️ 3. The weird twist (this is the important part)
Even in places labeled “Class III”…
➡️ Many NY “slot machines” are still:
* **Video Lottery Terminals (VLTs)**
* Not true Vegas-style slots
👉 Example:
* Tribal Class III casinos in NY often still use **lottery-controlled VLT-style machines** ([Professor Slots][3])
So you can be in a “Class III casino”…
…but the slots behave like a **lottery system under the hood**
---
# 🔍 Direct comparison
| Feature | Class III (Vegas-style) | NY Lottery Gaming (VLTs) |
| -------------------- | ----------------------- | ---------------------------- |
| Who you play against | House | Lottery system |
| Outcome | RNG in machine | Central system / ticket pool |
| Regulation | Tribal + state compact | State lottery |
| Strategy matters? | Sometimes (tables) | Usually no |
| Feels like casino? | Yes | Yes (but deceptive) |
---
# 🧩 So what is New York REALLY?
**Answer: It’s both.**
* ✔ YES — NY has real **Class III casino gaming**
* ✔ ALSO YES — a huge portion of machines are **lottery-based (VLTs)**
👉 In practice:
* Table games → **true Class III**
* Many “slots” → **lottery-style systems**
---
# 🧠 Bottom line (the honest answer)
New York casino gaming is:
> **A hybrid system where true Class III casino gaming exists, but a large share of electronic games function more like a state-run lottery than traditional casino slots.**
---
If you want, I can break down **which specific casinos in NY are “real” vs mostly VLT-based**—that’s where things get even more interesting (and a little deceptive depending on how you look at it).
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gambling_in_the_United_States?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Gambling in the United States"
[2]: https://gaming.ny.gov/indian-gaming?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Indian Gaming | Gaming Commission - NY.Gov"
[3]: https://professorslots.com/new-york-slot-machine-casino-gambling/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "New York Slot Machine Casino Gambling"
Quote: heatmapQuote: HunterhillI know they are not a tribe but I thought when NY state decided to allow gambling that they could be class111 casinos. So are del lago and resorts world Catskills class11 or class111?Quote: DieterQuote: HunterhillDoes anyone know if the slots are going to remain class11 or are they being changed to class111
link to original post
Genting is not a tribe!
link to original post
link to original post
Any tribal casino, that is in a state that ALSO has class 3, has the ability to offer class 3 casino products... probably pending approval or something like that before it happens
Take for instance in PA we have Wind Creek... in most of the other states Wind Creek is tribal... but since PA allows class 3 and Wind creek also exists in PA where other class 3 casinos exist, they can also offer class 3 games...
Im pretty sure what Im saying is from the IGRA website
link to original post
Class III means the gaming is conducted under tribal sovreignty, and regulated by the tribe's gaming commission.
General casino gaming is usually conducted by licensure of state authority, under regulation by the state gaming commission.
With a few exotic exceptions, the same games may be offered within either framework.
From that behavior, I'd assume Resorts World NYC had police checking ID's at the door and TITO's over $600 were taxable, but that was raised to $2,000 this year. But with this new upgrade in gambling license, the police may be removed from checking ID's at the door, and TITO's will no longer be taxable at the cage and may even have a $3K limit each at a kiosk. Table games, previously banned, that have side bets that pay 300 to 1 or better and pay over $2,000 will have a tax form. Normal sub-300 to 1 payouts will not be taxable despite being over $2,000. I'm looking at you, Mississippi Stud.
Quote: ChumpChangeSo Finger Lakes Race Track (VLT, racino) had police checking ID's at the door. I assume any TITO at the cage over $600 was taxable, that may have increased to $2,000 this year.
From that behavior, I'd assume Resorts World NYC had police checking ID's at the door and TITO's over $600 were taxable, but that was raised to $2,000 this year. But with this new upgrade in gambling license, the police may be removed from checking ID's at the door, and TITO's will no longer be taxable at the cage and may even have a $3K limit each at a kiosk. Table games, previously banned, that have side bets that pay 300 to 1 or better and pay over $2,000 will have a tax form. Normal sub-300 to 1 payouts will not be taxable despite being over $2,000. I'm looking at you, Mississippi Stud.
link to original post
VLT's are still under lottery commission rules, and many lottery commissions require ID for payouts over $600. This is separate from IRS rules.
edit: $600 or more.
Quote: ChumpChangeSo Finger Lakes Race Track (VLT, racino) had police checking ID's at the door. I assume any TITO at the cage over $600 was taxable, that may have increased to $2,000 this year.
From that behavior, I'd assume Resorts World NYC had police checking ID's at the door and TITO's over $600 were taxable, but that was raised to $2,000 this year. But with this new upgrade in gambling license, the police may be removed from checking ID's at the door, and TITO's will no longer be taxable at the cage and may even have a $3K limit each at a kiosk. Table games, previously banned, that have side bets that pay 300 to 1 or better and pay over $2,000 will have a tax form. Normal sub-300 to 1 payouts will not be taxable despite being over $2,000. I'm looking at you, Mississippi Stud.
link to original post
The $2000 limit is for Vegas style casinos. The VLT casinos will still have $600 as the limit. They have separate gaming commission rules. Which is why it's been $600 and not $1200 all this time.
As for the police at Finger Lakes, NYS law is racetrack security must be licensed police officers under the "peace officer" designation so they are police officers without guns basically.
Any VLT that is part of a racetrack must have these. Empire Casino in Yonkers also has police. All NYS casinos have security at the entrance per NYS law to prevent minors from entering. Some places check everyone's ID. Technically a choice of the casino. The police are just following the casinos rules
Resorts World in Aqueduct does NOT have them because the adjoining racetrack is a separate entity with different owners. However the actual racetrack has those same peace officers. So basically All the racetracks in NYS do. Those that are owned in conjunction with a VLT, the VLT facility will share the same peace officers rule.
The only other game I didn’t know about was Pai Gow Poker
There will be many more games in July
The owner Mr Lim cuts the ribbons .Alongside with Mr Lim legendary Queens rapper Nas rolls the ceremonial "first roll" of the dice at the new craps tables.


Four things I wanted to say:
1. I noticed the only game without a side bet here is Pai Gow Tiles. I have an idea for a progressive side bet for this game if anyone is interested in developing it with me.
2. To clarify blackjack rules, you can double after splitting and you can re-split aces.
3. I wouldn't have gone to the casino if people in this forum hadn't voiced doubts as to the veracity of my claims lol
4. I think that the diversity of table games here is pretty low given the size. There are 234 tables and only 11 games (Blackjack, Let It Ride, Crazy 4 Poker, Baccarat, Roulette, Pai Gow Tiles, Pai Gow Poker, Three Card Poker, Ultimate Texas HoldEm, Craps, and Mississippi Stud). The game with the most tables by far was Baccarat. I am certain that more diversity will be arriving in July - I'm especially hoping for some blackjack varieties! Perhaps the inside source who told me that there was going to be Spanish 21 was not incorrect, but actually referring to a game that will be available in the near future.
Quote: harrisJust got home.
Four things I wanted to say:
1. I noticed the only game without a side bet here is Pai Gow Tiles. I have an idea for a progressive side bet for this game if anyone is interested in developing it with me.
2. To clarify blackjack rules, you can double after splitting and you can re-split aces.
3. I wouldn't have gone to the casino if people in this forum hadn't voiced doubts as to the veracity of my claims lol
4. I think that the diversity of table games here is pretty low given the size. There are 234 tables and only 11 games (Blackjack, Let It Ride, Crazy 4 Poker, Baccarat, Roulette, Pai Gow Tiles, Pai Gow Poker, Three Card Poker, Ultimate Texas HoldEm, Craps, and Mississippi Stud). The game with the most tables by far was Baccarat. I am certain that more diversity will be arriving in July - I'm especially hoping for some blackjack varieties! Perhaps the inside source who told me that there was going to be Spanish 21 was not incorrect, but actually referring to a game that will be available in the near future.
link to original post
Can you see what sidebets are available on the baccarat tables? Maybe a pic?
Oh you're gone already...
The first side bets I saw on Baccarat were Moon 8, Sun 7, and Golden Talons
Then I saw the exact same thing but with a different name. I don't know why they would have identical side bets from different distributors.
Quote: harrisI don't think I've ever been allowed to take a picture of a table so I don't bother asking.
The first side bets I saw on Baccarat were Moon 8, Sun 7, and Golden Talons
Then I saw the exact same thing but with a different name. I don't know why they would have identical side bets from different distributors.
link to original post
a b test

I got a free T Shirt so it was worth it to get four hours of sleep

Quote: harris
I got a free T Shirt so it was worth it to get four hours of sleep
link to original post
You need to be more logical. It was worth it to spend four hours on visiting the new casino.
Quote: harris
I got a free T Shirt so it was worth it to get four hours of sleep
link to original post
But the city does not use subway tokens and no one under 50 would even recognize them.
Quote: itsmejeff
But the city does not use subway tokens and no one under 50 would even recognize them.
link to original post
Yeah I didn't know what this was until you mentioned it
The house edge should therefore be approximately 2.9%.
All fully packed with players.
A sea of Blackjack and Baccarat tables.
About half of them were open.
Blackjack pays 3:2, but the dealer hits on soft 17’s. Don’t know about Late Surrender.
Blackjack minimums were $50, $100, $200 and $500.
Lots of players at the $100 min tables.
Baccarat minimums were $100, $200, $500 and $1000.
The higher limit tables were staffed, but no one was playing.
The open $100 min tables were full.
They still have $5 min Stadium Baccarat on the second floor. Around 250 seats, and every one to them occupied.
The first floor is closed for renovations.
I’ll stick with PARX and Foxwoods.
Quote: itsmejeff
But the city does not use subway tokens and no one under 50 would even recognize them.
link to original post
What a coincidence, no one under 50 goes to this casino.
Good idea!
U stick with Fox & Parx
I stick with 9 casinos in AC
Hey
You can get a free ride ($38 fare less $50 casino credit) from this NYC Victoria Casino bus to AC

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h-kxlMfGoSc

