Manufacturer and gaming certification lab with different hold%?
Mark
Of course, a static algebraic analysis would always produce the same baseline result, but simulation runs are informative and required.
I know a gaming lab does the algebraic analysis of the game to get their results. I assume, perhaps incorrectly that the manufacturer does the math also. I find it interesting that their results can vary.
Mark
Quote: marksolbergCertainly any simulation may result in a variance between different trials. My assumption has always been that manufacturers "do the math" to come up with the actual theoretical return percentage. I'm sure they also run simulations to verify results and look at different aspects of the play of the game. I can't imagine a manufacturer relying on a simulation to generate an RTP number.
Well, imagine it: they do indeed do it this way. The math report I sent to Nevada Gaming and to GLI for EZ Pai Gow was required to have a simulation run example - not the flat algebraic math. The game has been out in real casinos for over two years now, and is doing fine.
Quote: marksolbergSend the game into the field and find that none of their simulations happen to hit the billion to one winning combination?
Games enter the field and go live all over the place. Casino operators track the coin-in, coin-out, and amount kept.
For table games, the table hold is examined, and is expected to have an aggregate table hold performance in the 5% to 35% range over time, the closer to 21% or so the better.
Let's put it this way: when car manufacturers (GM, Ford, Chrysler) measure a model's mpg, they do it by driving the car over many miles with diagnostic equipment attached to the car examing the car's performance, not just algebraicly (by computing the car's weight, engine displacement, areodynamic fatures, etc.)
Quote: marksolbergI know a gaming lab does the algebraic analysis of the game to get their results. I assume, perhaps incorrectly that the manufacturer does the math also. I find it interesting that their results can vary.
Well they do, and it's normal. So as long as it is within reasonable parameters, things are fine.
Distributors generally hire a known mathematician to perform the analysis, or have an on-staff mathematician do it.
I also know, from working at GLI, that they are not concerned with a difference of 0.1% on a skill game since the game won't play at theoretical anyhow. For a non-skill game, I would not expect their numbers to ever be more than 0.01% different than the manufacturers math. GLI will always put their number on the certification report in the event of a difference.
There is a game I'm working on now that I have estimated will take 65 days of calculations running 2 threads to find an exact solution. Instead, I'm opting for a week of simulation.
Mark
Join the discussion
Log in or create a free account to reply to this thread.

