Poll

3 votes (75%)
1 vote (25%)

4 members have voted

kenarman
kenarman
  • Threads: 28
  • Posts: 966
Joined: Nov 22, 2009
November 22nd, 2010 at 7:33:11 PM permalink
I have been thinking about thanksgiving and its roots and wondering if it has really changed much over the last several millennia.

All cultures have had a celebration after a successful harvest season. CHECK

It was celebration involving family and all members of the community CHECK

The highlight of the celebration was a ritualistic sacrifice of a human or some animal such as a goat. ALMOST We now have a ritualistic sacrifice of a bird.

Seems like we haven't actually changed much over the millenia.

Happy Thanksgiving everyone.
Be careful when you follow the masses, the M is sometimes silent.
ElectricDreams
ElectricDreams
  • Threads: 4
  • Posts: 194
Joined: Sep 8, 2010
November 22nd, 2010 at 7:39:20 PM permalink
I'm confused about the polling options - is Thanksgiving intended to be a religious holiday? I thought it was some business about pilgrims and Native Americans and whatnot.
Doc
Doc
  • Threads: 46
  • Posts: 7287
Joined: Feb 27, 2010
November 22nd, 2010 at 7:46:36 PM permalink
I'm also confused about the polling options -- isn't paganism a religion? Or is the question whether it is a celebration or a holiday?
Mosca
Mosca
  • Threads: 191
  • Posts: 4140
Joined: Dec 14, 2009
November 22nd, 2010 at 7:49:23 PM permalink
Quote: Doc

I'm also confused about the polling options -- isn't paganism a religion? Or is the question whether it is a celebration or a holiday?



I agree; "pagan" is non-Christian religion. If the choices were "religious" or "secular" it would make more sense. Or you could say "pagan" or "Christian"; it still wouldn't give enough choices, but it would make more sense.

I'd say Thanksgiving is pretty solidly secular.
A falling knife has no handle.
Doc
Doc
  • Threads: 46
  • Posts: 7287
Joined: Feb 27, 2010
November 22nd, 2010 at 7:55:23 PM permalink
Quote: Mosca

I agree; "pagan" is non-Christian religion. If the choices were "religious" or "secular" it would make more sense. Or you could say "pagan" or "Christian"; it still wouldn't give enough choices, but it would make more sense.

I'd say Thanksgiving is pretty solidly secular.

I think "paganism" is generally used to describe religions outside of all the "major" world religions, not just non-Christian. As for the issue of Thanksgiving being secular or not, two things come to mind: (a) To whom/what would you be giving thanks? (b) Hasn't Christmas become a secular holiday to a massive extent?
DJTeddyBear
DJTeddyBear
  • Threads: 207
  • Posts: 10992
Joined: Nov 2, 2009
November 22nd, 2010 at 8:00:51 PM permalink
If it was "Religious", "Pagen" or even "Secular", it would be celebrated outside of the United States.


Thanksgiving is an AMERICAN or national holiday.
I invented a few casino games. Info: http://www.DaveMillerGaming.com/ ————————————————————————————————————— Superstitions are silly, childish, irrational rituals, born out of fear of the unknown. But how much does it cost to knock on wood? 😁
Doc
Doc
  • Threads: 46
  • Posts: 7287
Joined: Feb 27, 2010
November 22nd, 2010 at 8:08:30 PM permalink
Quote: DJTeddyBear

Thanksgiving is an AMERICAN or national holiday.

I thought the Canadians just disagreed on the date.
kenarman
kenarman
  • Threads: 28
  • Posts: 966
Joined: Nov 22, 2009
November 22nd, 2010 at 8:09:51 PM permalink
Pagan celebration has two main definitions in Wikepedia 1. Any polytheistic religious celebration. 2. A narrower meaning is any non-Abrahamic religious celebration. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paganism

I was using the term in it's broader form. I believe that the original celebrations were definitely pagan religious celebrations.
Be careful when you follow the masses, the M is sometimes silent.
kenarman
kenarman
  • Threads: 28
  • Posts: 966
Joined: Nov 22, 2009
November 22nd, 2010 at 8:14:53 PM permalink
Quote: DJTeddyBear

If it was "Religious", "Pagen" or even "Secular", it would be celebrated outside of the United States.


Thanksgiving is an AMERICAN or national holiday.



That is partly my point celebrations for the end of harvest have been going on for a much longer time than America has existed. Canadians use the same name for the holiday but celebrate it earlier since the harvest season ends earlier when you are further north. Just the same as getting the football season over earlier.
Be careful when you follow the masses, the M is sometimes silent.
thecesspit
thecesspit
  • Threads: 53
  • Posts: 5936
Joined: Apr 19, 2010
November 22nd, 2010 at 8:31:19 PM permalink
Quote: kenarman

That is partly my point celebrations for the end of harvest have been going on for a much longer time than America has existed. Canadians use the same name for the holiday but celebrate it earlier since the harvest season ends earlier when you are further north. Just the same as getting the football season over earlier.



Martin Frobisher had the first Thanksgiving in North America in Newfoundland in 1578 on his return from a voyage to discover the North West passage. The early French settlers in Lower Canada also celebrated it as a custom from France.
"Then you can admire the real gambler, who has neither eaten, slept, thought nor lived, he has so smarted under the scourge of his martingale, so suffered on the rack of his desire for a coup at trente-et-quarante" - Honore de Balzac, 1829
Mosca
Mosca
  • Threads: 191
  • Posts: 4140
Joined: Dec 14, 2009
November 22nd, 2010 at 8:36:40 PM permalink
Quote: Doc

I think "paganism" is generally used to describe religions outside of all the "major" world religions, not just non-Christian. As for the issue of Thanksgiving being secular or not, two things come to mind: (a) To whom/what would you be giving thanks? (b) Hasn't Christmas become a secular holiday to a massive extent?



I still say it's pretty solidly secular. You can just be thankful for family and friends, you don't have to thank anything or anyone. You can feel at peace.

Yes, Christmas is also pretty solidly secular. My Jewish in-laws (sister's husband) have a tree and give presents. They get a kick out of it. Which doesn't preclude anyone from celebrating it as a religious holiday, but as a cultural event I'd say it's gone over to the other side.
A falling knife has no handle.
mkl654321
mkl654321
  • Threads: 65
  • Posts: 3412
Joined: Aug 8, 2010
November 22nd, 2010 at 9:43:50 PM permalink
Our ancient ancestors, dating back to caveman days, held a feast to celebrate the fall harvest. After the feast, they settled down in front of the television to watch the Lions game. But since electricty wouldn't be invented for millenia, they just stared at a blank screen until they all nodded off. We still do that today.
The fact that a believer is happier than a skeptic is no more to the point than the fact that a drunken man is happier than a sober one. The happiness of credulity is a cheap and dangerous quality.---George Bernard Shaw
ElectricDreams
ElectricDreams
  • Threads: 4
  • Posts: 194
Joined: Sep 8, 2010
November 22nd, 2010 at 10:10:57 PM permalink
Quote: mkl654321

Our ancient ancestors, dating back to caveman days, held a feast to celebrate the fall harvest. After the feast, they settled down in front of the television to watch the Lions game. But since electricty wouldn't be invented for millenia, they just stared at a blank screen until they all nodded off. We still do that today.



Of course, they weren't missing much becase the Lions sucked back then, too ;-)
thecesspit
thecesspit
  • Threads: 53
  • Posts: 5936
Joined: Apr 19, 2010
November 22nd, 2010 at 10:14:47 PM permalink
Quote: ElectricDreams

Of course, they weren't missing much becase the Lions sucked back then, too ;-)



Hey! They were great in the 50's and early 60's. I've been told.... :)
"Then you can admire the real gambler, who has neither eaten, slept, thought nor lived, he has so smarted under the scourge of his martingale, so suffered on the rack of his desire for a coup at trente-et-quarante" - Honore de Balzac, 1829
mkl654321
mkl654321
  • Threads: 65
  • Posts: 3412
Joined: Aug 8, 2010
November 22nd, 2010 at 10:38:10 PM permalink
Quote: thecesspit

Hey! They were great in the 50's and early 60's. I've been told.... :)



Yes. From A.D. 50 to A.D. 60, they were undefeated. Of course, they were always playing those patsies, the Christians.
The fact that a believer is happier than a skeptic is no more to the point than the fact that a drunken man is happier than a sober one. The happiness of credulity is a cheap and dangerous quality.---George Bernard Shaw
  • Jump to: