So, is more variance "good"? No one can decide that for anyone except him/herself, because no one else knows what your goal(s) is (are) in playing. If you're well-heeled and willing to risk a lot for a chance to win big, more variance gives you a better chance for that. If you have a very limited bankroll and want to play without much risk of losing a lot, low variance tends to "damp the swings".
Has anyone heard of the "doey-don't"? It is a system that damps out almost all variance on the comeout roll, in order to get past its disadvantage for the Don't Pass and lay odds on points, where the player is more likely to win and the casino pays true odds. This is how it works:
comeout: bet equal amounts on pass and don't pass
these will offset each other exactly, except for the 12
point established: the flat portions will always offset each other after a point is established; the player can then either take or lay odds in whatever multiples he/she wants, up to the maximum the casino allows
I believe the original idea was to lay odds on the DP.
The basic problem with this system, in my view, is that you are subject to the HA on BOTH bets. This is true of any hedge using partially-offsetting bets. I describe the doey-don't here only to illustrate a point about variance.
Let's look at only the flat-bet part of the doey-don't; it is the ultimate in low variance. In fact, you can NEVER win, only lose the pass on the 12. The expected value is about -1.4% of THE SUM of the two bets, and the standard deviation is 0.08 of the sum of both bets. The only variation comes from the random appearance of the 12. Any session of playing this way would have a range from zero (if the twelve never showed) to a loss equal to the bet unit times the number of twelves that showed on the comeout.
Of course, presumably no one would ever play this way; I'm just using it as an illustration of why variance is necessary in order for the player to have any chance to break even or win.
So, the house advantage is like a "cover charge" to buy variance from the casino. High-variance bets have higher HA; you're buying more variance. Look at these figures:
| HA | SD | |
|---|---|---|
| pass | .014 | .999 |
| place 6/8 | .015 | 1.079 |
| place 5/9 | .040 | 1.176 |
| buy 4/10 | .048 | 1.347 |
| Field (triple 12) | .028 | 1.142 |
| Field (double 12) | .056 | 1.079 |
| hard 6/8 | .091 | 2.875 |
| hard 4/10 | .111 | 2.514 |
| C&E | .111 | 2.132 |
| yo, 3 | .111 | 3.665 |
| 2, 12 | .139 | 5.094 |
| Big Red | .167 | 1.863 |
| World | .160 | 1.795 |
We see a general trend toward higher HA as SD goes up, although for Big Red and World you pay the highest HA and don't even get that much variance for it. Note, also, that the Field without the triple 12 not only has a higher HA, but lower variance, as well.
However, there is a way to get more variance without a higher HA; in fact, there is a way to get more variance without paying any additional HA at all: the odds bet behind the pass, don't pass, come and don't come. You can't make these bets by themselves, of course; you have to bet at least the table minimum on the flat part and the bet has to go to a point before you can take or lay odds, but the essential point is that the odds bet does not carry any HA itself. Why not?
There are two ways the casino builds the HA into bets:
1) charging a "vig" to make the bet, usually 5% of the bet amount, or the amount to be won, whichever is less.
2) paying less than the true odds of winning the bet
For example, when you place the six or eight, the odds against winning are 6 to 5, because there are six ways to roll a seven, against five to roll a six or eight; so, the payoff should be even money plus 20% (6/5 = 1.2) However, the payoff is 7 to 6, which is even money plus 16.7%; even if you win, you lose, so to speak, because the casino "short-changes" you. That's OK; they have to meet their expenses and make a profit, too.
On the odds bets, however, the casino actually pays you 6 to 5 on the 6/8, 3 to 2 on the 5/9 and 2 to 1 on the 4/10; they don't short you on the payoff.
Any of us who have read books about craps have seen the list of HAs for various multiples of odds taken, like:
pass + single odds: 0.83%
pass + double odds: 0.61%
pass + 5X odds: 0.33%
pass + 10X odds: 0.18%
etc. etc.
These are based on taking the expected loss and dividing it by the total of the flat and odds bets. OK, that's one way of looking at it, but I think it's misleading. The fact is that the expected loss is ALWAYS .014 times the FLAT BET. No matter how much you take or lay in odds, the expected loss does not change, because the expected value of the odds bet is always zero.
It's more illuminating to show the expected loss, a money amount or number of units, as:
expected loss
100 unit pass: 1.4 units
100 unit pass, single odds: 1.4 units
100 unit pass, double odds: 1.4 units
100 unit pass, 5X odds: 1.4 units
100 unit pass, 10X odds: 1.4 units
When you take or lay odds, you add variance, or call it volatility, not expected loss. Since the "handicap" remains the same, the higher variance (SD) means to don't have to be as lucky to overcome the handicap. However, you don't have to be as unlucky to get clobbered, either, since volatility works both ways.
Remember the two million people playing pass for two hours? Suppose those people had taken double odds on every point, still assuming they had enough bankroll to always last the two hours? The graph of all their results would still have the same peak, at about -1 unit, but it would have been a lot more spread out, with a lot wider range between the best and worst outcomes. Also, a lot more people would have come out ahead, about 48% instead of less than 43%, but those who lost would have lost more, because variance is symmetrical absent bankroll considerations.
Obviously, when you take or lay odds, you are risking more money, which means if the dice don't cooperate you will lose money faster and perhaps bust your session bankroll or reach your loss tolerance. Many people advocate progressive betting, where you start out at a minimum amount and increase bets after wins. Of course, the drawback is that when you increase a bet and lose, you throw away some past winnings. Progressions rely on streaks. A couple of members had a conversation about the relative merits of straight progression versus a regress-then-progress system that locks up an initial win. In my view, neither is "better", and it depends on the flow of the dice which comes out ahead in any given session. Consider, however, that progressing place bets always results in higher expected loss, because every dollar is subject to the HA; however, if you progress odds bets instead of place bets the expected loss does not increase, and if you have access to a casino that allows a high odds multiple, you can go quite a way without ever increasing your flat bet. Of course, you don't have as much flexibility, because you can only make the odds bets when there is a point, which happens roughly two-thirds of the time.
Consider this, assuming the casino allows 10X odds:
start at minimum pass bet
ignore comeout results
after a point win, take single odds on the next point
if you lose a point with odds, go back to the start
if you win another point, take double odds on the next point
etc. etc.
You can be as aggressive as you like, or you can put in a regression somewhere. If you do reach max odds and win, add one unit to the flat bet, etc.
Cheers,
Alan Shank


Comments (1)
As you pointed out Big Red and World are the two biggest sucker bets on the craps table. Big HA and no variance.
The smartest thing is to mostly avoid the proposition bets in craps, but if you crave some variance then switch to roulette where you can bet 1:9 1:12 1:18 and 1:36 at much lower house advantage.