Written by myself.
Some of you are now or have just graduated college and congratulations to you. Below is my commencement address and advice:
You all have made it all the way! This is something to be proud of indeed. Now, maybe you are expecting "some dude to rush up and offer you a job!" Unlikely to happen, but you will soon enter the workforce. Welcome to the real world--next exit 40 years. But seriously, I have been where you are and I have hired people like you before. So instead of a pep talk, I will give you the most direct 10 career points no one else will dare give,
1. I'm your new boss and have been at my company for some time now, maybe 10 years or more. I have more years experience than you have months. I'm not interested in your ideas on how the operation should be run. We survived before you and we most likely will be here after you. You will be given a job to do and I expect it to be done. It will probably be unsexy, repetitive, and boring. I still need it done. Do it right and I may ask you for suggestions, that is the time to say. Don't be offended if I do not use your ideas.
2. I'm your boss. B-O-S-S. I am not one of your college professors. When we have a meeting I am not looking for you to challenge my ideas. Unless I say it is a brainstorming session, the purpose of the meeting is for you to listen to how I want things done.
3. This is a job, not college. Attendance is mandatory. You do not get "3 cuts" before you get your grade lowered. You want to party on a Wednesday night I damn well expect you in the office at 100% on Thursday morning.
4. You don't yet even know what you don't know. Your degree here just proves you are able to learn and will stick to something. Learning my business might mean working at a dirty, stinky job in a uniform. I expect you to do that.
5. Your classes might have mentioned all these wonderful things companies offer like "flex time" and "telecommuting." You will not be doing that. Most jobs do not work with telecommuting and the people that get that privilege have been with me for years. Flex time must still be worked around the needs of the business.
6. It is going to be a year before you get to take a week's vacation. When that does happen don't expect Christmas week and don't expect the day after Thanksgiving off, either. My senior employees have that off. You might even be given a calendar of just the weeks available and asked what you prefer.
7. If you are very lucky you might be getting a company car. Expect a Ford or Chevy and expect it to be very plain, possibly used. Senior execs get the Cadillacs, Audis and BMWs. You are not a senior exec.
8. Sooner or later you will meet my boss. If you want an easier job, keep my boss off my back. When you talk with my boss, keep it light. Let him ask the questions. Talk about sports, the weather, whatever but DO NOT APPEAL MY DECISIONS TO MY BOSS-EVER! There is a chain of command and when you break it, it causes all kinds of issues.
9. I don't care about your self-esteem. I don't have time for giving you constant feedback. I care only that you provide me and my department more in output than you are being paid. You graduated college, you are smart enough to know when you are not pulling the cart but rather riding in it.
10. You have your degree, but see that guy over there? He is not interested in getting my job, but he knows his up and down. People in the plant look to him for leadership. He has been doing his job longer than you have been alive, sport. Want to lose his and every body's respect in an instant?! Just go over there and explain how he is doing it all wrong.
Well, class, that is all I have time for. Work just keeps one so busy, but you will see what I mean in no time. God Bless America


Comments (6)
I like this, and perhaps it should be put into a laminated pamphlet and handed to college graduates along with their diploma!
Perhaps the only one I (only slightly) disagree with is #2. I'm always willing to listen to people's ideas, even if I think they are wrong. Sometimes new innovations come, not necessarily from what someone else's idea is, but from something that idea sparks. Also, sometimes we get into ruts where we are doing something just because "that's the way it's always been done".
I might change number 2: I am your boss, not a college professor. I do things the way they are done, not to annoy you, but because of certain reasons that you may not even know about. I encourage you to ask questions, and present ideas, but do not get discouraged if I don't like your ideas, or if I have reasons to not accept them. But if I do tell you to do things a certain way, make sure you do them that way.
@konceptum--yes, #2 come off a bit harsh but it is supposed to be a bit of satire. Here is why my point is made as it is. We keep reading about "teams" and "worker input." Well, when I first ran a place one guy actually said, "hey, don't you read that companies are seeking worker input these days?" Problem was he wasn't getting his work done which was costing me money and he was there barely a few months which was kind of the "why" as you said. Then at meetings sometimes I'd be giving training and be told, "Wouldn't this work better?" I agree that there are times a fresh face has a new idea, but too many grads and MBA grads come in with the idea they are some Lou Gerstner brought in to save IBM and the current management is clueless. Current management may struggle and may even need to be changed but is probably not clueless.
One other thing I thought of: My freshman year in college, I had a class where we got put into teams and assigned a programming project. About a month into the project, some of the teams must have been having difficulty. In class, the professor said that he had gotten some complaints about people on projects not pulling their weight, and that this might have a negative effect on grades. His response? Tough. "In the real world, you are often put into teams with other co-workers who may or may not do their fair share of the work. You have no choice on what teams you are put on. You can either quit your job, or suck it up and make sure that the work assigned to the group gets done." This was the only professor I ever had who approached group assignments in this manner. I think some graduating college students (mainly those without job experience) have this misconception that everybody in the working world will pull their own weight. As those of us with job experience knows, this isn't always true. I think graduating college students should be told that sometimes they will have to, and be expected to, do more work than they are being paid for. Sometimes that leads to better job opportunities, and other times it just leads to long days at the office. :)
AZ -
That little phrase is probably the scariest and most honest thing in the entire speech.WOW. That was dead on perfect.
I'd like to hear some well-respected honoree read that at a graduation.
'Not always true'? How about never true!
There's a joke about it here at my job. "How many people work at ___?"
A lot of customers know the punch line: "About half of them."
That's covered in #9.
@ One other thing I thought of: My freshman year in college, I had a class where we got put into teams and assigned a programming project. About a month into the project, some of the teams must have been having difficulty. In class, the professor said that he had gotten some complaints about people on projects not pulling their weight, and that this might have a negative effect on grades. His response? Tough
I had a college prof, my best prof in fact, she had a policy on this. You were assigned teams but you could be "fired" from a team. I don't remember but am sure there was at least a warning first. But if you were fired you then had to get another team to take you on. She said right off that you would be asking to be "hired" as a known deadbeat. No one was ever "fired" but one "quit" and went to another team. It was very effective knowing if you were fired you would not be able to pass. Not that I needed the motivation but some do.
So right on! I agree who heartedly and I'm on the younger side, working entry level and in the middle of getting my 2nd BA (already have one in business management, and have been working on a 2nd in hospitality management for ages.)
If I had it to do over again or if I could get a fresh out of high school kid to listen to me. I'd advocate learning a trade (you know the kind of things that are free/cheap and quick to learn in a community college) and working that until you are 24 and then consider traditional college. First off they'd learn real world actual work experience, 2nd they would earn an income they can save, 3rd after 24 financial aid is based on your income + assets versus your parents (I think it's absurd that college financial aid automatically assumes mommy and daddy will foot the bill) and it is much easier to get +EV things like the pell grant.
The thing that turned me off most about college (I took way longer than 4 years for my first degree and paid for much of it out of my own pocket after disappointing my parents) was the other students. There outlook on the work world was far to rosy and they were way to entitled. I remember one class where the professor played a mock game of "Deal or No Deal" (kinda childish), and offered student/contestants entry level positions with starting salary and benefits ect. It was disconcerting how many would "no deal", laugh, and scoff at $25,000, $30,000, and even $40,000 staring pay offers for fresh out of college entry level positions. I hope my classmates got a reality check when the economy burst in real life. College has become far too much of a fantasy, fun, party time, live it up while you can, and I/my financial aid/my parents pay my tuition so I'm entitled (basically buying) the right to pass/get good grades with little to no work and just by having the piece of paper at the end I deserve a huge salary place. Not a place for people who really want to learn something. I like it much better now, I have a "real" job, own my own home, pay my own bills, I go to class keep my mouth shut for the most part, get good grades (haven't ever had less than a 4.0 in this program) and laugh silently in my head about all the over optimistic, entitled, immature silliness all around me.
I think we had it more correct in the past when kids fresh out of high school went straight to the work force, or even more so in renaissance times when kids were taught a trade early on.