Poll
6 votes (18.75%) | |||
21 votes (65.62%) | |||
4 votes (12.5%) | |||
1 vote (3.12%) |
32 members have voted
We have come across a gray area of player ethics as to what is "right" and what is "kinda wrong."
The idea is this, similar to Bait Car on TruTV - bust a petty thief.
It would work like this - and do chime in what you think would happen:
1. Casino prints "dead" or non-redeemable ticket-out vouchers of varying sums, and places them at strategic locations throughout the casino.
2. Voucher HAS a fictious PLAYER card number attached to it.
3. Alledged Face value of.... oh, let's say $137.50, or $210.00, or $87.75, random amounts that are large enough to get people to debate themselves, "Should I return it - or CASH IT!" :)
If a player picks it up and returns it to a Slot Attendant or to Security, the player gets a comp: Buffet passes for two, a bottle of Champaign, a couple of Movie tickets, and a thank you for being a rare good citizen.
If a player goes to a ticket redemption cashout machine, the player gets prompted something like "Verify your card numbers as 86571428 (Y/N)?" or "Are you D. Miller?"
If the player now lies as to his identity, the machine takes a snapshot, and security talks to him. NO arrest, beat-down, what have, just a short lecture that:
1. If it ain't your money - it shouldn't be in your hand, AND:
2. You DID claim you were someone else WHEN PROMPTED.
Maybe they can have a wall of Shame, like the Wall of Winners kind of thing.....
As to entrapment, if the tickets were for twenty thousand dollars it might be entrapment but for a paltry sum, its not entrapment. It provided the opportunity but not the motivation.
I think the casino might be better off dealing with actual events rather than creating events.
Casino reality? Focus on the cleavage, not the silicone. Focus on the ecstatic winners, not the dejected losers. Get smiling photographs of people with large checks up on the wall. There is no need to create temptation about a cash-out ticket, just create an interest in the games.
Quote: Paigowdan2. Voucher HAS a fictious PLAYER card number attached to it.
Do slot tickets even have the player card info on them?
Now "Bait Car" is not, people get arrested for real on tape.
Point is, "How much policing does the average person need when easy money is involved?"
Quote: NareedDo slot tickets even have the player card info on them?
Yes - if the player played on his card. That's how he racks up points.
Even if he played uncarded, the voucher's session info has the date/time and machine number stamp, and surveillance footage can be seen for the player in action at that machine at that time.
Quote: PaigowdanYes - if the player played on his card. That's how he racks up points.
Even if he played uncarded, the voucher's session info has the date/time and machine number stamp, and surveillance footage can be seen for the player in action at that machine at that time.
Not exactly -- most gaming tickets are anonymous upon inspection. The validation codes, asset IDs, and other info in the ticket system's record can be used to identify the player and/or the player tracking card used for each pull while the machine was being played, but the ticket itself doesn't actually say "Joe Smith, Loyalty Card #123-45-6789" on it anywhere. Presumably that information could be programmed to display on a ticket, but I've never seen a player ticket with that information printed on it.
Quote: s2dbakerThis is not a good idea for a casino. I mean it's great for the honest people but the quasi-scum (which I would imagine is a lot of people) would be lost as customers forever. Ask yourself, would you ever return to a casino that intentionally tricked you into cashing a fake ticket? Because people like that are always that victims in their own minds and will play the victim card until the cows come home and then insist that they were victimized by the cows.
I'll drink milk to that! Again, this is a discussion point. Bait Car is NOT coming to a casino near you!
Do know that some players are great sabateurs for a casino, utter vandals, where their loss is actually no loss, or even a gain for everybody.
Look at it this way: if you owned a restaurant, but one particular customer has a habit of screaming at your other customers and publicly vomiting, you would not be saying, "Oh! What a shame it is to lose his business!" Even if he is saying, "I was victimized by being barred from this restaurant, - and I will never come back!! My feelings were HURT!" Doesn't matter, good riddance is simply that in a lot of these cases.
Quote: MathExtremistNot exactly -- most gaming tickets are anonymous upon inspection. The validation codes, asset IDs, and other info in the ticket system's record can be used to identify the player and/or the player tracking card used for each pull while the machine was being played, but the ticket itself doesn't actually say "Joe Smith, Loyalty Card #123-45-6789" on it anywhere. Presumably that information could be programmed to display on a ticket, but I've never seen a player ticket with that information printed on it.
Stacy - that info is not printed in Plain English right on the ticket, true. I wasn't implying this. There is a machine number and a time stamp, a bar code.
No directly human readable info is on the ticket - it is anonymous to the reader's eye. It is coded so that all the info is tracked, and that the cash out machine and the slot department knows this info.
How do casinos know what their coin-in and coin-out is?
How do they know how many points a player has earned from his play?
How do they know which machines are getting action, and which are not - and when?
If a Gaming Control Board agent came in to a casino with a slot voucher, and said to the Slot Director: "We need you to tell us which machine this came from, when it was played on, what the average bet was, what the player's buy-in (coin-in) was, what the cash out was, and the surveillance footage of the player playing on this machine..."
They would be able to do so.
BTW Dan, you seem to have very strong feelings against players. I'm not criticizing you, after all most people develop a deep dislike of their customers; you meet way too many jerks, I know I do. But it does mean I take your statements on players with a grain of salt.
---
But seriously, I like the idea of a reality show. Of course, it would have to be set up so that those who try to cash it learn the truth without getting a set of stainless steel bracelets.
Quote: ColoradoJIt wouldn't be a bad idea, if I could bet on the outcome.
I like how you think!
Quote: DJTeddyBearBut seriously, I like the idea of a reality show. Of course, it would have to be set up so that those who try to cash it learn the truth without getting a set of stainless steel bracelets.
The U.S. would be tough...but a Singapore Casino??!! Perfect fit.
Enforcement AND Entertainment - combined into one!
I will say, though, that while I'd love to see a all of these scumbags dealt with more harshly than a simple tsk-tsk, it would be quite foolish for a casino to do so. It's kind of funny too. To take Dan's screaming patron a step further, most any other business under the sun you'd want to immediately identify and exclude any scoundrels and scallywags post-haste, yet in our industry, these parasites are just asked to return what they've taken, if caught, and are told to enjoy their day and hope to see you again. I hate it, yet agree it's in the best interest of the casino.
A view on the human condition? Got it already. Here's the Face's perspective from my time on the job. If it's unattended, it's taken. $181.79 or whatever Dan quoted is totally not necessary. Some of the people are what we call "fleas" (jump from machine to machine, never play, just take tickets) and take anything of value, including the $0.03 left on a penny machine. But any regular Joe, save for maybe the $100 a spin guys, take anything worth $1 or more. $1 credit on a machine? Printed and taken. $10 on the floor? Taken. Cell phone? Gonzo. Purse? If it's not found where it's left, 94% chance you find it empty in the bathroom. Envelope full of money? Yoink. The only things returned are things not of immediate value, like jackets, sweaters, cheap wallets with just ID and reciepts inside, you know, just random personal goods. The only demographics I've seen regularly turn in cash or cash equivelent items are 60-70 year old COUPLES, and 21-26 yr old men (chances of 21-26 yr old men taking it increase by 15% for each tatoo visible). By a landslide, the worst pilferers are skinny, chain smoking men in their 40's, and even worse than them, the champions of sticky fingers, 50-60 yr old single women.
If getting caught in one of Dan's stings caused people to not return out of anger or embarassment, the casino would be empty within the year. Of course my examples are stereotypical, and of course I don't see all, but I'd bet only the most cynical of people would be unfazed by the shenanigans I've seen on the job. There are definately more people that just mind their own than there are who regularly perform assholic duties, but I have found there are a lot more asshats out there than I ever would have guessed.
Quote: FaceIf getting caught in one of Dan's stings caused people to not return out of anger or embarassment, the casino would be empty within the year.
Actually, I disagree - if all establishments enforce some standards. Again, this is a thought experiment. BUT....
Keep in mind that people will adapt to higher standards if uniformly enorced, I do believe. Also, most nickel joints would run much better with everyone behaving themselves...
If all we lost were the petty thieves, it would be a gain....
The unlucky and impulsive ... which, come to think of it, are probably very easy to find in a casino.Quote: PaigowdanIf all we lost were the petty thieves, it would be a gain....
What casino would tolerate this sort of stuff? Sure they might want to teach the fleas a lesson from time to time. Heck, you ever see a cheating dealer NOT get arrested on shift and paraded past all the coworkers on the way to the back room?
What does a casino care about general morality or honesty. Are they going to start reading the faxes sent via the business center to see if businessmen are not screwing their employees?
Busted? He met a young woman at a party, they hit it off and wound up in his hotel room or something. This is a subject for tabloid TV all of a sudden???Quote: AyecarumbaI think this is a great idea for MSNBC's "To Catch a Predator"... Oh wait, the host got busted... never mind.
Do I hate that jerk? You bet... he seems to just parot what people say to him on those predator shows. And I sure don't think that organization Dateline partners with is legitimate. There are lots of young girls who include his name in their prayers each night because without him they wouldn't be making as much money. Most of those creeps he trapped were bottom-feeding scum who trekked miles to meet those girls and must surely be desperate. It doesn't take much to look at those idiots and see they need a good endocrinology work up.
But I see no reason why his own personal life should be a matter of public concern. Frankly, these days, I doubt its even of any concern to his wife. She probably knows he met a young newsanchor at a party and wound up in the sack with her a few times. Its no big deal to anyone.
Also, I'd like to know what the expiration policy is on slot tickets of said casino? If it is less than forever, or at least a year, I think they are in no position to lecture anybody. I find expiration dates a trick to get players to throw tickets away once they get back home and find a ticket in their wallet. That just happened to me as I left the Reno, I still had a $24 ticket from the Atlantis. I know the probability they will honor it after expiration is high, so it is tacked to my bulletin board until my next Reno visit, but not everybody knows casino policy as well as I do. Most people just toss anything small.
Once I planned to do a survey where I let tickets expire to a bunch of casinos and then tried to cash them. My intent was to shame those who refused them, but everybody accepted them. If anyone can think of a more successful experiment where I can entrap dishonest casinos, let me know.
In closing, I've told this story before, but I'd like to give a good word to the Luxor. Once I hit a royal there, was paid, and then left. However, I still had about $500 in credits on the machine. I know stupid, but that is me, I am always forgetting things. About two months later somebody from the Luxor calls and asks me when I'm going to come in and ask for my ticket. This caught me totally by surprise and he explained what happened, and they ended up mailing me a check.
As long as it isn't about the buffet :PQuote: WizardI'd like to give a good word to the Luxor.
I wouldn't necessarily refer to a casino as dishonest. The lawyers and the accountants insist that there be an expiration date. The casino knows that there is no reason they need abide by it. They honor the ticket, you are more likely to spend the money right there in the casino anyway. I'd have published your study anyway.Quote: WizardIf anyone can think of a more successful experiment where I can entrap dishonest casinos, let me know.
The dishonesty is more endemic to the offers and the advertising. "Loose" slot machines is but one example. Rude waitresses or rude security guards are a source of complaints but it rarely reflects any casino dishonesty, usually its more the arrogance of low level employees. Security guards that yell at someone photographing the casino's marquee are stupid. The VP of advertising loves that to happen. One guard came on very strong about a guy photographing cloud formations from the parking structure. Heck just ask the guy to stop doing it ... what does the casino care about some nut who likes to phtograph cloud patterns particularly when he also likes to gamble and eat at that casino?
Now when South Point put new chips in ten percent of their slot machines and milked it for all it was worth is that dishonesty? Are arbitrary and capricious policies on "heat" for card counters dishonesty?
Most casinos stop promoting any "deal" well before it ends and will even continue to give people various special deals if they have recently expired simply because they want to maintain good will and a two for one meal special isn't such a big deal to them.
Its an industry where frankness is not highly rated but as long as they are not shaving the dice it seems okay. I hate that 6:5 in foot tall letters but its all over the place. Its sort of like a strip club with their "and six ugly ones"... it often turns out to be true.
Quote: FleaStiffI wouldn't necessarily refer to a casino as dishonest. The lawyers and the accountants insist that there be an expiration date. The casino knows that there is no reason they need abide by it. They honor the ticket, you are more likely to spend the money right there in the casino anyway. I'd have published your study anyway.
Perhaps "dishonest" was putting it too strong. However, I fail to see why they can't be a year, as opposed to the usual 30 or 60 days. Again, I think it is a trick to get the player to throw the ticket away. Much worse are the casinos that refuse to honor expired slot and sports tickets.
Quote:The dishonesty is more endemic to the offers and the advertising. "Loose" slot machines is but one example.
I'm thinking of adding a section to my site examining the truth, or lack thereof, behind such "loose" claims. Usually the fine print will say they are based against county averages. For example, the El Cortez claims their slots are 32% looser than the Clark County average. I think the way they get that figure is, for example, the Clark County average is 92%, and the El Cortez is at 94.56%. So the house edge is 32% less. Where I have a problem with that is applying the "loose" statistic to the casino's piece of the pie. In my opinion, the word "loose" should be applied to the return, in which case they would be only 2.78% looser in this example.
Still, I find that just a semantic issue, and not worth making a big issue over. I have a much harder time with Hooters' $200 free "promotional" slot play offer for new players, which is probably worth less then $5.
AND WHO SAYS SHE DID ANYTHING WRONG TO START WITH. I often discard ticked with less than 30 cents on them and I don't want to be bothered. Who says i don't have that right! It was ticket, not the casino's. I have the right to do a random act of kindness without some Dickless Tracy acting on my behalf.
Quote: PaigowdanActually, I disagree - if all establishments enforce some standards. Again, this is a thought experiment. BUT....
Keep in mind that people will adapt to higher standards if uniformly enorced, I do believe. Also, most nickel joints would run much better with everyone behaving themselves...
If all we lost were the petty thieves, it would be a gain....
I agree with your point of establishing higher standards, for sure. And losing petty thieves? That works for me, less tedious reviews and irritating investigations for me to do. I was just saying that there was a far greater number of these types of people than I ever would have guessed. My natural estimation of how many of these people existed in the casino in a given time frame would be somewhere around one every week or two. My experience has shown it to be several per day. I don't think the casino would wish to shun several people per day.
I would just pocket the ticket, if I ever found one. And I am not immoral, I am just rational. If it said "Mr. Such-and-such" on it, then, I probably would not. Now, the question - why does not casino print the player's name on the ticket?
And yes, $37.50 is more than enough for us to trouble ourselves with. My personal low record was pre-teens, $11 and change maybe? And I'm but 1 of about 25 people who do this, so the company record may be lower still. If it has value enough for you to take it, it probably has value enough for the proper owner to want it. Please procede with your finding to the nearest Security Officer and sleep well in an aura of righteousness =)
Quote: PaigowdanThe U.S. would be tough...but a Singapore Casino??!! Perfect fit.
Enforcement AND Entertainment - combined into one!
Given the cultural "law and order" training in Singapore, it would be interesting to see if there would be any scofflaws there.
And they would the ones to try the "decoy cashout voucher" scenario if anyone is. If buy-and-bust isn't entrapment....
Quote: AyecarumbaGiven the cultural "law and order" training in Singapore, it would be interesting to see if there would be any scofflaws there.
Depends. i know vandalizing a car gets you caning. But what would stealing a slot ticket rate? Boiling in oil? Or maybe just life without parole?
Quote: gofaster87Well this seems to have stemmed from my announcement of a lady getting arrested for a 5 cent voucher. Everyone else is talking of larger amounts that may be significant. The other night I walked through a casino and saw 3 abandoned vouchers, all in the cents , that were set on top of the machine. I see people abandon small vouchers purposely all the time or leave the last cent in the machine because they cant get a full spin. These insignificant amounts are ridiculous and are no gray area for ethics. For this to bother someone on such a level that they call people petty thieves for picking up a few cents is beyond me. Look at how many people pick up lucky pennies, big superstition especially in casinos. These people are not borderline criminals. Get a life people.
AMEN !!!!
Quote: weaselmanIf the name of the owner (or card number, or something) was displayed on the ticket, I think a majority of people would take it to the security.
This seems to me an excellent idea. Personalizing the ticket connects it to a real human being in a way a bar code doesn't: "Hey, Gladys Schwartz dropped her ticket." Fleas and thieves will always be with us, but I agree a name on a ticket may help most people return it to security.
Of course, it requires the use of a player's card.
I also foresee problems when a player forgets their card in a machine. The next person could come along and put money in, before realizing that there was already a card registered. How do they get their money back if they can't rightfully cash the ticket out?
Quote:Many players prefer to remain anonymous, especially if they put together many wins that are just under the IRS reporting threshold.
Certainly. Anyone is free to play anonymously.
Quote:The next person could come along and put money in, before realizing that there was already a card registered. How do they get their money back if they can't rightfully cash the ticket out?
Cash the ticket, keep your deposit, return the rest to the cage with the card.
Quote: AyecarumbaRequiring a player's card to cash out will create a new set of problems. Many players prefer to remain anonymous, especially if they put together many wins that are just under the IRS reporting threshold.
My idea was for security. Look up thread for it. Briefly, if a player has his card in the machine and wins anything, the ticket can only be cashed concurrently with the player card, be it at the cashing machine or the cage. If the player dind't use a card, then noe would be required to cash the ticket, but the ticket wouldn't be protected against theft or loss.
This would help if you lose a ticket or ahve one stolen. the casino could simply void the original one, so no machine would cash it, and issue you a new one. meantime if a thief or a lucky passer by tries to cash it, they won't be able to since they lack the player card.
Quote:I also foresee problems when a player forgets their card in a machine. The next person could come along and put money in, before realizing that there was already a card registered. How do they get their money back if they can't rightfully cash the ticket out?
Good one. I've nothing to say to that beyond "always check the card slot before buying in." But I'll give it some more thought.
Quote: MathExtremistI have a small collection of $0.01 slot vouchers that I use as bookmarks. It's always a good conversation starter and the ticket paper is surprisingly durable.
I tried collecting those once, but they kept fading - especially if I left them in direct sunlight accidentally. How do you keep yours in good condition?
Quote: AyecarumbaMany players prefer to remain anonymous, especially if they put together many wins that are just under the IRS reporting threshold.
Presumably someone putting together many wins just under the IRS threshold is a lot more careful than average with his consistently plump winnings. But, of course, even the best of us . . .
Quote: ThatDonGuyI tried collecting those once, but they kept fading - especially if I left them in direct sunlight accidentally. How do you keep yours in good condition?
I live in Oregon. :)
Seriously, any heat source (including sunlight) will cause problems -- it even says on the back of the ticket that they're thermal-printed. I usually have mine tucked away in books. They're not good candidates for true collectibles in that displaying them will make them fade over time.
Not revealed is whether the cabbie who had just scored the voucher did so by way of a tip given him by a passenger or whether he merely happened to encounter the ticket while taking a turn through the Golden Nugget's slot machine pit. I will give him the benefit of the doubt and assume it was a tip.
If a ticket had a name on it, then I'd turn it in. But just because a ticket has a serial number, like a piece of US currency, does not mean that an owner could be identified. I'm not going to turn it in so that the casino can stick it in their pocket. It is no more theirs than it is mine. I also learned "finders keepers" in Kindergarten.
Quote: kpIf I were to come across a $100 bill, or a $100 chip, or $100 voucher, and there was no obvious owner (i.e. I did not see it fall out of someone's pocket), then I would pocket it. Just like I learned in Kindergarten with the old nursery rhyme - "find a penny, pick it up...".
If a ticket had a name on it, then I'd turn it in. But just because a ticket has a serial number, like a piece of US currency, does not mean that an owner could be identified. I'm not going to turn it in so that the casino can stick it in their pocket. It is no more theirs than it is mine. I also learned "finders keepers" in Kindergarten.
Sheriff Face and Deputy Dan will be with you shortly !