So after my casino journey to Philadelphia, I learned I had one casino left in PA to get to. I work in retail, and a day off this time of year is valuable. So after getting laundry done, groceries bought and DVR shows watched I decided to complete my chip collection of the PA casinos. I wanted to do the trip before the weather gets bad (as it was, we had flurries last night, but nothing serious at any point on my drive). First stop, Erie, PA...
PRESQUE ISLE DOWNS AND CASINO- This casino is owned by MTR Gaming, how also owns Mountaineer Casino in West Virginia. If you've never been to Mountaineer (I've only been once), it's HIGHLY themed to the "Roarin' 20's." Outside of the silly dealer and cocktail outfits like at Resorts AC, all the slots and casino areas are set up like Prohibition era Chicago. At Mountaineer, it's very fun, and seems to work. Apparently, they feel they can take the same theme and do it at Presque Isle... unfortunately, they can't. It's a jumbled mess and definitely the cheapest looking of the PA casinos. It actually reminded me of older Native American casinos.
So the theme is half-assed, but at least the table minimums are lower than what I expected. I thought I'd see higher mins as Cleveland doesn't have an operating casino yet. Most poker games, roulette and craps were all $5, BJ was $10 and Pai Gow Poker at $15. BJ rules are standard PA rules: s17, surrender available, DAS, DA2, No RSA. Craps didn't have odds posted, but stingy field. There are maybe a TOTAL of 10 VP machines that aren't bar top. The schedules are pretty lousy too.
I decided to play some poker. I had a hard time finding the poker room, despite what I thought was a sign clearly pointing it out near the buffet. It's actually upstairs, way away from the main casino, and in it's own room. The game is 1-3, and the table I sat at was basically a bunch of gamblers. I tried to "bluff" once, got called, but still had a better hand than the caller. I played a bit too tight, then too loose, so after losing $200, I decided to give it up. My reads were okay, but it's hard to read hardcore gamblers.
I went down to Pai Gow Poker. It was a $15 min, $300 max on the main bet. They had $500 chips, which I found kind of odd. Then, I saw the table, which is the standard bonus table in Vegas. However, the bets spread on the bonus was $1-100. It also had a $40,000 maximum aggregate. This would really screw the main bettor if at a full table with envy payouts. Anyways, I had some good luck on the table, and didn't lose a hand for a while (I pushed a bunch). After losing my first one, I walked up $30. I decided I would go ahead and make the drive out to Niagara Falls.
SENECA NIAGARA- So apparently Seneca Nation covers a lot of Western New York. It's interesting to see signs saying when you are NY, and when you aren't. The casino, located in Niagara Falls, NY, is located in Seneca Territory. It is across the pond from Canada, and if you have a passport, there are two other casinos you can visit. I unfortunately do not have one (I miss the days of just needing a birth certificate). I found a creepy self-park area (there was a nice garage I apparently missed) and headed on in.
I knew this casino was big, but I was surprised by how overwhelming the main area is. It's in a hangar and it feels huge. When the table games area seemed small, I knew there was more to it. I walked around for a bit, and found a Three Card Poker table with... get this... the old pay table on the Pairs Plus!!! It was a $10 min, but I was so overjoyed to see a 4-1 table, I sat down and played. I got my card set up through the table and got a flush! Woo hoo, a 4-1 payout! Shortly after that, I got a 3-of-a-kind (6's, so apparently I'm the devil) and left the table after a dealer hot streak up $225!
I walked around trying to find both the cashier and the poker room. The cashier was back in the main hangar area. On the way, I found an empty Spanish 21 table (S17). I decided to give it a go... big mistake. It doesn't matter if I play perfect strategy lately... I'm on a nasty streak in this game. I need to just give up Blackjack cold turkey, but it's hard when you enjoy it. If I keep up on this nastiness, I will probably hate it, so give it a few more shoes.
To make a long story short, I ended down $80 on that table. I cashed out, and tried to find the player's club booth so I could get the $10 free slot play on my card. I asked a security guard where the player's club booth was. He said "What?" I said "Where you get a player's card" He said, "Oh you mean Promotions." Am I so Midwest that I'm the only one who uses that terminology?? Well, I got the $10 set up and played some 7-5 Bonus Poker and cashed out with $15. For those keeping track, the whole trip I'm only down $10, and technically $8 since I had two $1 chips in my pocket. I decided to do the extra hour drive and made my way to Salamanca, NY.
SENECA ALLEGANY- The road was very backroads to get there, but eventually I saw the casino sign on the hotel. The parking garage was quite tall and a TON of spaces were roped off, why I have no idea. I walked in, and saw the table games area.
Btw, BJ rules at both casinos are S17, NO RSA, No Surrender, split to up to 3 hands. When I got here, they had a lot of $5 tables. There were only about 33 tables in two pits. This is clearly an afterthought to the much bigger and nicer Niagara. I went to the craps tables (5x odds) and let a lady finish her roll. She left, and I did my roll. I caught a point and a few come bets, and afterwards, was up $9. I decided being down $1 in gambling for the trip was fine, so I walked around a bit, and headed back to Ohio.
Overall, the trip, while a bit whirlwind, was a lot of fun. I don't see myself going up there again, as game selection was surprisingly limited at the Seneca casinos. My experience has been that the Native American casinos are looser on rules and often have the newest and best options... this was simply not the case here. But I can now say I've driven in New York....
Next stop, Tunica, this weekend. Then it's a break from casinos until mid-January.


Comments (5)
You think $80 is bad? Try $325, in two hours, betting $10 the whole time at S21 at Horseshoe Hammond. Still the most bizarre session I've had.
You mean, like, a whole dollar?
Sounds like a win to me! LOL
Seneca Niagara's casinos are looser as they are competing for Canadians. Sorry you couldn't come over to my side of the river. Fallsview is quite nice.
Yup, sucks about the passport. I lost a lot with that mess.
The Seneca Nation actually doesn't cover much at all. In fact, in the Falls only the casino grounds are it's territory. Cross the street and you're back in NY (but don't cross the street, it's yucky up there =p) I feel ya on the garage, though. Been there for training probably 15 times and I still don't know how to get in, I always use the self park lol. Did you happen to look up while you were there? They have an old school cat walk like in the movies, where we can go out with binocs and scope the floor.
Too bad you couldn't pop over the river to the land of Molson and strange money. I haven't been to Fallsview in 12 years, but I remember it being nice there. Plus there's more to do, and less of that feeling you're about to be shanked.
Make fun of my commute if you'd like, but I never have to worry about traffic. Deer, dogs, occasional pigs and loosed farm cows, yes, but no traffic. ;) Kinda funny you mentioned the garage; it's been going on for 3 weeks and none of us know either. But you'll find no better sunset view than from the roof of that garage. Just stunning. Allegany is much more slots focused, as I'm sure you can tell. There's just not enough population to support much else, all other tables and table games have come and gone, moved out for more BJ or more slots.
Thanks for stopping by! Just don't come in winter. Our BJ may be 3:2, but that's also the ration of roads that get plowed to those that don't.
The roped-off garage at Salameca may be due to a new hotel tower coming soon. The place is always booked so a new tower is going in. Lots of OH plates in the lot and they seem to get some acts in the showroom that helps fill it. If they would just put say $10 per room to pave I-86 above standards of the Bangledesh DOT it might be nicer yet.
As for Presque Isle, well, having gone to college in Edinboro I am sad to say Erie locals just do not have the highest of expectations after the fall the city has taken economically since the mid 1970s. Only city I ever lived in where they sports leads with local high school results and "we will have NFL scores right after this commercial!" So I am not suprised the casino is as you say.
You can get into and out of Canada w/o a passport if you have an enhanced drivers license. I just have a passport but some people don't want one or can't wait. It is complicated so do know before you go.