HSI Review/Trip Report (part 1)- 10/15-16

Tiltpoul
By Tiltpoul
Oct 18, 2011 · 3 min read
As anybody who has read any of my posts knows, I tend to play at a lot of Caesars/Harrah's properties, mostly because I have moved around a lot and they have casinos near everywhere I've lived. I am a Diamond member and have been now for 7 years. I value the program as it gets me more free rooms and amenities across the country than any other player club. Of course, for the most part the gaming isn't quite as good, but there is one exception: Horseshoe Southern Indiana (hereby known as HSI).

First off, a little history about HSI. It started out as Caesars years ago in Harrison County, IN. This is significant because this was legally the closest they could get to nearby Louisville, KY. Of course, Kentucky has made a big push against casino gambling in the interests of horse owners and the Kentucky Derby. For some reason, both Floyd County and New Albany was adamantly against it, so it went right across the border to Harrison County. This leaves basically a casino with no real commerce nearby. No gas station, no retail (outside of casino properties), no other hotels... nothing.

About 6 years ago, when Harrah's bought the Caesars properties, they decided to sell Harrah's East Chicago and keep the license to Horseshoe Hammond and Caesars. In a marketing strategy to make their properties branded, they decided to change Caesars (the 'resort casino') to a Horseshoe (the 'gamblers casino'). The result led to a property wide renovation and rebranding, although they stayed on the current riverboat, which is the largest to house a casino in the country. Unfortunately, the locals didn't really get the rebranding, and many got upset that they were no longer good enough to have a Caesars. As an outsider, I think the move made a lot of sense, although they should have gone onto a larger barge, IMHO...

Horseshoe Casino does have a hotel on the property. Due to an Indian burial ground and potential flooding near the river and creek that runs through the property, the hotel is located roughly a 1/2 mile from the casino. To me, this has long been the only serious complaint I've had with Horseshoe. The hotel is a little sub-par compared to nicer and newer Harrah's properties, and certainly three steps below a Caesars property, but the beds are comfortable and the rates are reasonable, given the lack of competition nearby.

As a Diamond player, I rarely have to pay a room rate. I decided at the last minute to book for Saturday night, 10/15. When I checked online on Friday night and even Saturday afternoon, I got a rate of $99.99 (Sunday was comped). I called the reservation number at 7:00pm, and they quoted me a price of $79.99. I accepted the rate, and arrived around 8:30pm. I had a two queen room. The bathroom does have a separate room for the toilet, but the shower is substandard, and there is no nice tub. One time they put me in a JR Suite, and that did have a separate jacuuzzi tub and shower, and the room was a bit larger.

They do require a $50 deposit, cash or credit. However, Diamond players get free WiFi access. They do have a pool and hot tub, but it's usually run over by children (remember, there is NOTHING for them to do here). There is a little cafe in the hotel lobby, called Aroma, and it has some nice fare, albeit way overpriced if paying by cash... (more on that in a minute).

As I mentioned earlier, the casino is a bit of a walk from the hotel, but they do offer a shuttle most hours of the day. They do have a few moving walkways to help speed the journey up. Eventually, there is a pavilion with the Paula Deen Buffet, a Graeters Ice Cream parlor, Bijoux Terner, the Convention Center, a casino gift shop, JB's Steakhouse and the sports bar, Legends. There is also a new Asian themed restaurant opening up soon, called Pearl.

I have eaten at Legends (good, two and half out of four stars), and the Buffet (three out of four stars, it's VERY rich though, as most everything has pounds of butter in it). I will say the decor of the Buffet is really nice, the furniture is very exquisite and it's set up like a house, which to me is quite unique. The food is standard Southern buffet food, but I like nearly everything on the spread, and the desserts, while minimal by comparison, are AMAZING!

I've decided to do this a two-part review, as I'm tired now and need to get to bed... more to come soon!

Comments (3)

teddys
teddys Oct 18, 2011

HSI decided to give me a lot of freebies which I've taken advantage of. I feel they have too many drawbacks, however; the location, hotel distance and poor food options are just three. (I have to disagree with you on Paula Deen's -- can't stand it). The free WiFi for Diamonds is very nice and I probably overvalue it more than it's worth. The pool also sucks, as you mentioned.

Is the I-64 bridge still out?

FleaStiff
FleaStiff Oct 19, 2011

If its a Casino in a Cornfield it will draw gamblers. The trouble is that gamblers have wives and kids and there is always going to be a need for some sort of amenities. A pool, an arcade, a movie theater, an upscale shop that a wife can at least walk through for awhile, something. Distance to the hotel can be cured by a shuttle and a jovial driver, but a dearth of non-gambling opportunities condemns the casino to a customer base of gamblers. That is great for the casino in the short term but eventually the wives will put their foot down and end it. Perhaps an air conditioned shop with a glass wall that overlooks the kids in the pool? Perhaps a teen arcade? Perhaps a good selection of premium TV channels? Perhaps a spa?... but there has to be something.

Tiltpoul
Tiltpoul Oct 19, 2011

The I-64 bridge IS out, and will be for at least another 6 months. I'll cover this more in part 2, which I hope to write this evening. However, the casino is hurting, BIG TIME, because of it.



I can't see them expanding shopping outlets or an arcade, as it really isn't a family destination; this is part of the reason it's a HORSESHOE instead of Caesars now. It's in the weird position of being more than a locals casino (as the distance is just too far from Louisville to be local), and a destination casino (because there is nothing there to bring the people in). As far as a shuttle, I'm sure there would be no problem from Indiana, but Kentucky has actively fought against the casino, and in fact, there's a law out there that would arrest everybody aboard if the boat were to cross the Kentucky line. I'm sure someone would fight a shuttle there from Louisville.

All posts in Tiltpoul's blog · All member blogs