I'm thinking WTF.
I ask the dealer if he can use his phone during the hand. The dealer said, yes. It looked as if the kid was googleing something. I'm now imagining he is using to help calculate pot odds or something. Finally I just called time on the kid.
I thought for sure the dealer was wrong.
I asked the poker shift manager if someone was allowed to use the internet on there phone during a hand. She said, "yes absolutely" I went one step further and asked if they can use it to calculate pot odds or make decisions. She said, "yes, as long as they are not slowing down the game to much."
Seriously, can this be true?
What is the law regarding this? I think the original rule was intended for simple communication.Quote: WizardI don't play much live poker, but it seems a standard rule you can't use a cell phone at house-banked games. Just yesterday a friend of mine was rebuked for doing this at the Cosmo. It doesn't seem fair that players can use a "device" against against other players but not the house. It also goes against the spirit of poker.
Quote: AxelWolfWhat is the law regarding this? I think the original rule was intended for simple communication.
I'm on an attorney, but might the "device" law cover this situation?
1. Projects the outcome of the game;
2. Keeps track of cards played or cards prepared for play in the game;
3. Analyzes the probability of the occurrence of an event relating to the game; or
4. Analyzes the strategy for playing or betting to be used in the game,
Ê except as may be made available as part of an approved game or otherwise permitted by the Commission.
(Added to NRS by 1985, 970; A 2011, 216; 2013, 1317)
Quote: DRich3. Analyzes the probability of the occurrence of an event relating to the game; or
4. Analyzes the strategy for playing or betting to be used in the game,
Doesn't this mean you can't use a VP app while playing VP?
I did bring that up to the shift manager, not that she really knows. But she clearly insisted you could use your phone to assist you. I was so dumbfounded I asked a few other employees, they all said the same thing. I specifically asked what the managers name was but I forgot already. I am going to ask a day shift manager and confirm this is in fact their official policy.Quote: WizardI'm on an attorney, but might the "device" law cover this situation?
Was this in the Rio poker room or in the WSOP side games?
Quote: tongniSo, uh, yeah, no phone while you're in a hand.
That may be your preference, and mine, but to repeat, you will NOT find that to be the standard. And yeah, they are very well aware of chapter and verse of NRS as well as Gaming's Administrative Rules & application of it to them specifically. The long-time "go-to" guy on poker rules for years on this site below happens to be a fellow who is not only very prominent among poker dealers in Southern Nevada, now also supervisor in the largest room in the State, but also an attorney, and it happens that he also doesn't like it, but in multiple conversations on this topic with him, room managers, and some of the most knowledgeable poker room staff in town left no doubt that it IS up to the poker rooms' choice of house rule. Here are the few related threads I happen to have links handy for, but I think there have been at least a few dozen on this topic over the last half decade:
http://www.pokeratlas.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=75&t=20761&sid=724ebb1359d6ffd34a9ec48404053c13
http://www.pokeratlas.com/search?q=cell+phone+during+hand
Quote: AxelWolfI did bring that up to the shift manager, not that she really knows. But she clearly insisted you could use your phone to assist you. I was so dumbfounded I asked a few other employees, they all said the same thing. I specifically asked what the managers name was but I forgot already. I am going to ask a day shift manager and confirm this is in fact their official policy.
You could always have called gaming if you felt that the law was being violated.
Having said that, the law says that you can't use the device to help you, not that you can't use the device. The guy could claim that he was just texting his wife telling her to pick up milk or something. Can you prove otherwise?
The largest (and widely regarded as best) rooms with the most games and highest stakes now provide outlets at the table so you don't have to run your battery down, and installed poker-room specific wifi networks some time ago.Quote: DRichNRS 465.075
<SNIP>
Ê except as may be made available as part of an approved game or otherwise permitted by the Commission.
If you doubt this, try calling them to ask. Here's one: Aria poker room (702) 590-7230; and another: Wynn poker room (702) 770-7654; and another Venetian poker room: (702) 414-7657. And that comprises 3 of the 4 biggest rooms in Nevada, together amounting to more than 60% of the total volume of poker on the Las Vegas Strip.
I'm not attempting to argue merits, just what most definitely IS if you get around to local poker rooms.
Yes indeed. And, it would not be the first time, or the second, or the third, or the tenth time about this specific question. But if one feels they know both the law and administrative rules that apply to Nevada poker rooms in this matter better, or you just want to be really sure about what you're told because it feels very wrong to you, than by all means, do go for it. And, you can even make that call to Gaming Enforcement from your seat at the poker table without missing a blind! NGE Las Vegas division - Phone: (702) 486-2020Quote: AxiomOfChoiceYou could always have called gaming if you felt that the law was being violated.
Quote: NareedDoesn't this mean you can't use a VP app while playing VP?
Yes it does.
Quote: DRichYes it does.
(Cue ominous music)
So much for my idea of carrying strategies for several games on my tablet next trip.
But you can use a strategy printed on paper.
Quote: AxelWolfShe said, "yes, as long as they are not slowing down the game too much."
obv he was slowing down the game.
I personally have seen Andy Bloch playing on Full Tilt on a tablet, whilst seated at the WSOP some years ago. lol as if playing in the main event was boring him enough that he had to keep busy playing online at the same time.
And greetings to ya, Zip.
Quote: zippyboyobv he was slowing down the game.
I personally have seen Andy Bloch playing on Full Tilt on a tablet, whilst seated at the WSOP some years ago. lol as if playing in the main event was boring him enough that he had to keep busy playing online at the same time.
I have that same concern. And I could go on at some length about why I believe it isn't just a hypothetical concern, but that'd totally derail the thread as I got into chapter & verse about what my former neighbor was up to. Not hard to imagine. He rigged ways he actually colluded with himself online.Quote: IbeatyouracesIt's reasons like these as to why I won't gamble online. Especially poker!
Many poker rooms will disqualify a bad beat hand if any player, even those out of the hand, are using a device.
Quote: AxelWolfShe said, "yes, as long as they are not slowing down the game to much."
Define "too much".
I think the answer is going to be that you have to call the clock.
You might choose to think that. And there are gradations here: such as 'at the table' vs. 'in a hand.' And to muddle it further, there are rooms that choose to have a more restrictive rule for tournament play than for cash games. But reality is you will in fact find that it is common, not universal at all but definitely common, for "don't slow the game" to be the rule, including large high-end rooms. If you want to know, you have to ask at the specific room you are playing, even sometimes within the same company. (BTW, Rio is NOT a 'large high end room' at all outside of the WSOP.)Quote: DJTeddyBearYeah, many poker rooms provide electric strips on the underside of the tables so you can charge your device. But I would think that that's so you can keep charged, and use the device when you're not in a hand.
Many poker rooms will disqualify a bad beat hand if any player, even those out of the hand, are using a device.
Define "too much".
I think the answer is going to be that you have to call the clock.
I've seen players in hands using their phones -- whether or not they are using this app I don't know.
I don't like it.
The rule at many poker casinos in the LA area is that texting on a phone is okay always and even in tournaments. You can talk on a cell phone in a cash game. You cannot talk on a cell phone in a tournament. I didn't make the rules -- that's just what the rules are at several of the big casinos here.
Personally I think the rule should be: No phones at any time at the table. If you want to use your phone get up from the table. If you are in a hand you cannot get up from the table to use your phone.
That applies to all "house rules." I.E. Forward motion, betting line, whether a partial undeclared raise is a call or a min raise, etc. They can all be different for cash vs tourney even in the same poker room.Quote: DrawingDeadAnd to muddle it further, there are rooms that choose to have a more restrictive rule for tournament play than for cash games.
P.S. ...Quote: DJTeddyBearDefine "too much".Quote: AxelWolfShe said, "yes, as long as they are not slowing down the game to much."
I don't use my phone while in a hand. If my phone rings when I'm in a hand, and it's not my wife, I'll ignore it. Otherwise, I'll answer it and without saying 'Hello', I say "I'm in a hand. Gimme a minute." Then, without waiting for a reply, I put the phone down until the hand is over. I've never gotten a comment about that. Therefore, I gotta think that anything longer than that would be "too much."
I mean when I play I liked to know whether I had a 1/2 or 1/3 chance of making the hand, or 8/48 of drawing the straight. But after all the years of play you would have a rough figure in your head. And whats the difference between a 34.5% and a 41.25% chance anyway?
If you are playing BJ, then that 2% makes a HUGE difference, but in poker, the human factor out weights it completely.
Playing against other people? Sure, use anything you want.
Playing against the house? (blackjack) Sorry nothing is allowed
Quote: BatMannThis goes to show you how casino makes their rules.
Playing against other people? Sure, use anything you want.
Playing against the house? (blackjack) Sorry nothing is allowed
Just to clarify, you are "not allowed" to enter the cards dealt into your phone while playing blackjack? What about someone standing behind you?
Our craps expert and former professional player, Ahigh, once showed us a mickey mouse record keeper of dice results and says he was ejected from said casino due to having it. In Baccarat of course you can chart anything you wish, same with roulette.
Quote: zippyboyobv he was slowing down the game.
I personally have seen Andy Bloch playing on Full Tilt on a tablet, whilst seated at the WSOP some years ago. lol as if playing in the main event was boring him enough that he had to keep busy playing online at the same time.
But was he playing on full tilt while activitely in the hand? On your phone while in a hand is way different than while folded. Last poker session, I played some Words with Friends with my mother between hands since Missouri revoked their all electronic devices banned at all times rule because poker players younger than me complained about it.
How do.I know he is not ? After I am 86 if it comes to that, and it might, gaming will get a call. I do not have to sit there and be cheated.
Sometimes being civil is just bullshit.
Will you become similarly agitated when a device output is in audio form, say through earbuds? Stock up on those throat lozenges, or find a different hobby.Quote: BuzzardMy money in the pot and you think I am gonna sit there while he texts someone for advice. No way !
How do.I know he is not ? After I am 86 if it comes to that, and it might, gaming will get a call. I do not have to sit there and be cheated.
Sometimes being civil is just bullshit.
Quote: DrawingDeadWill you become similarly agitated when a device output is in audio form, say through earbuds? Stock up on those throat lozenges, or find a different hobby.
Letting anyone get any outside help in determining a decision in a hand is not allowed. It would not be fair for the person who is waiting for a call/raise/fold from another who has a buddy on the phone running odds, etc.
Correct. And this does not at all equal "how do I know that someone isn't..." Use of audio output from electronic devices, amounting to another fancy way of saying listening to music while playing, is nearly universal at poker tables and has been for quite a long while now. "How do I know someone isn't...?" Oh joy.Quote: djatcLetting anyone get any outside help in determining a decision in a hand is not allowed.
Cheating does sometimes happen in some form, likely not very often but sometimes, and people who are experienced players do not generally choose this as one of their first targets to get most concerned about. Not that I'm trying to dismiss the possibility, I've said I personally prefer a "not while in the hand" rule. But I do know of a couple of teams that were actually colluding, or trying to (most teams are not very good), including at some tables where I was playing, and this kind of thing wasn't a method they chose as practical before they eventually got identified and booted. I think probably for good reason they didn't try this, because I think it isn't nearly as good for them as the simple old fashioned methods that the folks most exercised about phones would probably be the most oblivious to.
Regardless of whether you agree with my view on that or not, audio output connected to a device (generally comprised of music from your phone to your earbuds) is something that's going to continue to be allowed pretty much everywhere poker is played regardless of your status during a hand at least in Las Vegas, so the task is to decide what is the sensible way you want to accept and deal with that simple fact, because it is a fact that sure isn't going anywhere.
He folded so I don't know what he had.Quote: rainmanAxel, Did you win the pot? I assume you did, who had what?
I'm not going to bitch and complain about this. I just want to know the law regarding this. I was absolutely shocked at the answer I got when I specifically asked about the use of a phone to get poker odds. If its legal and casino allowed, perhaps I will join the movement and deliberately do it to prove my point. I'll find a way to use it to my advantage. If people start using there phones to calculate odds and help them play poker, I doubt this rule will last long.
Enough cheating going on as it is.
Of course be a reasonable man, I would be receptive to looking at his tablet or cell phone will he does it. Might even whisper something in his ear as I did.
All above comments are for texting while in a hand. Yeah, 86 is an option. Lots of other rooms to play in. Sure would be careful to NOT knock any stacks over, but you know sometimes I am clumsy lol