Would "gay marriage" open a door that should stay shut?
Thread Rating:
As I haven't seen this angle brought up here (possible I missed it, I'm new...) I thought I'd toss it out there and see what others think.
For the record, I'll give my position on gay marriage so that any hidden agenda I may be harboring will be exposed. Personally, I don't think the state should be in the marriage business. I think that what we now call marriage should be redefined as a civil union and any 2 people* should be allowed to get one. If you want to be married I think that should be a separate deal that is between the parties involved and the church/whatever organization chooses to sanction the marriage.
* Uh oh, now I've gone and left the door open for blood relatives to get hitched, this is complicated stuff. :)
Anyway, if you choose to respond this I'd really appreciate it if you could stay to the main subject and leave picking apart my personal position for another time/thread (feel free to start it if it'll make your day brighter) as I only included it for background and transparency.
Discuss!
And you're right. I don't think polygamy has been discussed here before. I think we can all agree that polygamy would be an entirely different debate, although there probably will not be an agreement on the percentages of people on either side of that one. Does leagizing gay marriage open the door to polygamy? Maybe. But certainly not immediately. Would any state that is against gay marriage even entertain the thought of legalizing polygamy? Doubtful.
For the record, I'm straight and married, but I support gay rights and gay marriage.
Whenever the opportunity presents itself, I'll write to my congressperson this simple comment:
Don't same sex couples have a right to a bitter, messy divorce?
Polygamy? Sure. Why not? As long as everyone is loving and accepting, go for it. "Love." Isn't that what it's all about?
On a side note, I always get a chuckle when I hear people talk about gays like it's a disease. If it really were a disease, wouldn't you be happy that they are taking themselves out of the gene pool?
It's main highlight is this definition of marriage:
"Marriage - certain aspects of capacity
2. Marriage, for civil purposes, is the lawful union of two persons to the exclusion of all others. "
No polygamy.
How would a gay church marriage, between two people you do not know and have never met, be against YOUR religious freedom?
Would it be correct to assume that you're not against a gay church wedding if the church itself is not against gay marriage?
Quote: Gabes22[..] but to ask a preacher to perform a celebration of Holy Matrimony, when the church he is serving is blantantly against that, is asking to much and is a direct violation of my religious freedom.
I'm against compelling a church of any kind to perform any ceremony that goes against its institutional beliefs. That would be a violation of religious freedom. But merely asking a church or a priest, as long as they can refuse, is not even unethical (unless it's done as nuissance).
Quote: NareedI'm against compelling a church of any kind to perform any ceremony that goes against its institutional beliefs. That would be a violation of religious freedom. But merely asking a church or a priest, as long as they can refuse, is not even unethical (unless it's done as nuissance).
You should all move to Canada:
" Religious officials
3. It is recognized that officials of religious groups are free to refuse to perform marriages that are not in accordance with their religious beliefs. "
I'm kinda surprised that you would look for an outdoor wedding. A Catholic wedding requires a mass, which means an indoor church wedding.
dwheatley -
While I don't know of any specific law, why would anyone want to force an officiant to do their wedding if the officiant was reluctant to perform?
Quote: dwheatleyYou should all move to Canada:
" Religious officials
3. It is recognized that officials of religious groups are free to refuse to perform marriages that are not in accordance with their religious beliefs. "
Wasn't the inclusion of a similar statement the last thing needed to get New York to recognize same-sex marriages? IIRC, it was one vote short of passage in one of the houses of New York's legislature, because a couple of members were afraid that, as written, if a church refused to marry a same-sex couple, it could have its tax-exempt status revoked on discrimination grounds.
Besides - if you think your church has a problem because of this, go form another church. Isn't "I have a problem with the existing religions" the reason pretty much every church exists?
Quote: Abram27I am gay tolerant.
Although I'm straight myself and I like women. By the way, babes from the MFC sex cam categorysatisfy me the best. It's hard to find a sexual partner during quarantine, so webcams are the best option.
Assuming this is a mathematical question, besides it is a mathematical forum....
On the surface I can see a mathematical difference, all else being equal, between a couple "XX" and a couple "XY" turning into XXX XXY or XYY. Assuming a couple wanted to turn into a threesome (where I live you can't marry a third person, but let's assume you live in a country where you can) then for a "XX" couple to add another "X" both parties, presumably, would be relatively willing. It seems less likely, unless an arrangement to allow a natural parent, to go to "XXY". However for a "XY" couple it is likely that "X" might be happy with an extra "Y", but "Y" might not. So at a guess it seems more likely that "XX" pairs would turn into a triple than "XY".
Join the discussion
Log in or create a free account to reply to this thread.

